State Rep. Melissa Sargent (D-Madison) introduced bills to legalize marijuana in Wisconsin during each of the past three legislative sessions. Sargent says she has heard from many constituents about the benefits of using marijuana and the harm of marijuana-related arrests and convictions. She is seen at UW-Madison on Jan. 31, 2019. Photos by Coburn Dukehart / Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism.
by Suzie Kazar, Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism
Gary Storck has been here before.
For decades, Storck, a longtime medical marijuana advocate from Madison, has been pushing the state Legislature to legalize his medicine. Storck suffers from glaucoma. He uses cannabis to slow the progression of the disease, which is gradually robbing him of his sight.
The first big moment was in 2002, when statewide polling found that 80.3 percent of Wisconsinites supported medical marijuana. Storck was ecstatic. When he first heard the numbers, âI jumped in the air about a foot, I think. I was so happy to see that level of support.â
Storck was convinced that this would be the moment to finally legalize medical marijuana. Volunteers from Is My Medicine Legal Yet?, a group that Storck co-founded, placed copies of the polling results in every office at the State Capitol.
âWe thought, they see this, theyâre going to pass it,â Storck said. âWell, it didnât happen.â A bipartisan bill sponsored by former Republican Rep. Gregg Underheim of Oshkosh did not make it out of committee.
In 2009, Wisconsin Democrats swept into power and took control of the governorâs office, the Assembly and the Senate. Medical marijuana was back on the table, with help from politicians including Sen. Jon Erpenbach (D-West Point). Political support seemed to be on the upswing.
That year, a public hearing was held. âPeople came from all over the state,â Storck said. âIt was an eight-hour, standing-room-only public hearing. A lot of patients, they drove so far, and they were waiting and waiting, and they had to leave.â
Fifty-five people spoke in favor of the bill; another 49 registered in favor. Five people spoke against it.
âIt seemed like the stars had aligned for us,â Storck said.
But the bill, unable to garner enough bipartisan support, never got a vote. Powerful interests, including the Wisconsin Medical Society and the Wisconsin Department of Justice, were opposed.
Medical marijuana legal in 33 states
Although Wisconsinâs laws on marijuana have stayed largely the same â and federal law continues to ban use and sales â bordering states have begun to move on the issue. Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota have all legalized medical marijuana, with Michigan also legalizing recreational use in 2018.
Overall, the medical use of cannabis is legal in 33 states, along with the District of Columbia and several U.S. territories. Recreational use is legal in 10 of those states plus D.C. A legalization push in New Jersey, which is controlled by Democrats, recently failed after lawmakers could not reach consensus.
If Illinois were to legalize recreational marijuana â which newly elected Democratic Gov. J.B. Pritzker lists as one of his top priorities â Wisconsin residents could drive a short distance for an over-the-counter purchase. With such easy access, Storck said, âI donât know how long prohibition can last.â
Milwaukee County District Attorney John Chisholm believes legalization is imminent.
âThe reason I say itâs coming is that pretty much across the state, law enforcement has de-emphasized marijuana enforcement, particularly for possession,â said Chisholm, a Democrat. He noted that in many areas, police officers prefer to give tickets rather than arrest those caught for possession of small amounts of marijuana.
Democratic Gov. Tony Evers has announced proposals to legalize medical marijuana in Wisconsin, decriminalize possession of small amounts of the drug, allow expungement for possession charges and update state laws governing cannabidiol, or CBD, a non-intoxicating, over-the-counter treatment for anxiety, seizures and inflammation.
Evers has also said he would consider legalization of recreational use if voters approved it in a statewide referendum.
Support for legalization grows
Eversâ proposals have been lauded by Democratic state legislators â and even some top law-enforcement officials â who have seen support for legalization grow in Wisconsin in recent years. In January, a Marquette Law School Poll found that 58 percent of Wisconsinites believe marijuana should be legalized and regulated like alcohol, with 36 percent opposed.
In November, local advisory-only referendua in support of marijuana legalization were passed in large numbers across the state, including 16 counties and two cities. Whether the question was about medical or recreational marijuana, no measure passed with less than 60 percent support, and no measure was rejected.
Voters in both the Village of Egg Harbor and the City of Sturgeon Bay approved nonbinding referenda in the April 2 election for both medical and recreational marijuana.
Eversâ plan could help standardize marijuana enforcement in the state. The city of Milwaukee and Dane County have already decriminalized possession of small amounts of marijuana. However, other jurisdictions continue to aggressively enforce anti-possession laws, Dane County Sheriff Dave Mahoney said.
A first offense for possession can be charged as a misdemeanor and carries a maximum penalty of six months in jail and a $1,000 fine. Subsequent offenses can be charged as a felony and carry a maximum penalty of 3.5 years in prison and a $10,000 fine.
Although Mahoney, a Democrat, has no problem with residents of Dane County who are âsmoking a doobie,â he said statewide law-enforcement groups would oppose legalizing marijuana for recreational use. Mahoney said he has moved toward the center of the legalization debate â in part because members of his family use cannabis medicinally â but he does not support recreational marijuana at this time.
âI want to see more research,â Mahoney said.
Eversâ plan has also been endorsed by other Wisconsin top law-enforcement officials, including Chisholm, who believes the proposal could help to reduce disparities in how marijuana possession is treated around the state.
âI think that what the governorâs attempting to do is just saying, âLook, major sections of (local) ordinances allow less than 25 grams to be a ticket (rather than a crime),ââ Chisholm said. âWhy not just incorporate that into the state law, and that does away with some of the unequal enforcement rates.â
GOP leaders not on board
Assembly Speaker Robin Vos (R-Rochester) opposes most of Eversâ plan.
The governorâs proposal âmakes it easier to get recreational marijuana and provides a pathway to full legalization, which I do not support. Iâm open to medical marijuana when itâs prescribed by a doctor, but it has to be done in a targeted way without allowing recreational use,â Vos said in a statement.
In an email, an aide to Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald (R-Juneau) reiterated his previous positions in opposition of legalization. Fitzgerald also has been quoted as saying he does not believe there is enough support within the Republican-controlled Senate for movement on the proposals.
And there are groups, including Smart Approaches to Marijuana (SAM), that would likely mobilize if Wisconsin proposes legalizing the drug for recreational use. SAM spokesperson Colton Grace said the group pushes for alternatives in states considering legalization, including allowing medicinal uses as approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
âWe donât support the status quo âŚ we support decriminalization,â Grace said. The groupâs message: âDecriminalize, donât legalize.â
Eversâ cancer leads to cannabis support
An important provision of the proposals is the legalization of medical marijuana, which Evers says was influenced by his experience as a cancer patient. Evers beat esophageal cancer about 10 years ago. Some cancer patients use marijuana to combat nausea from chemotherapy and curb cancer pain.
Alan Robinson, executive director of the Wisconsin chapter of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML), said he uses cannabis to reduce symptoms of anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress order, or PTSD, which he developed after the drug-overdose death of a close friend.
âIt wasnât until a friend urged me to smoke weed that I began to feel some relief,â said Robinson, who sports dress socks featuring marijuana leaves. âThis was the first time that I had slept the whole night through in years, and it was life-changing.â
Currently, the FDA has approved only one drug, Epidiolex, that contains an active component of marijuana. Epidiolex is used to treat seizures related to two rare syndromes. Three other FDA-approved drugs â Marinol, Syndros and Cesamet â contain synthetically derived components. Marinol and Syndros are approved to prevent weight loss in AIDS patients, and Cesamet treats nausea and vomiting in cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy.
Greg Kinsley is a medical marijuana advocate with Crohnâs disease, an inflammatory bowel disease that can cause abdominal pain and severe diarrhea. In 2014, Kinsley used a doctorâs note to avoid possession charges under an obscure Wisconsin law that allows patients to have a controlled substance with a valid prescription or order.
Kinsley believes it is time to legalize.
âWe are a country of laws,â he said. âIf the lawâs not quite right, we as a people need to change that.â
Legalization has popular support
Rep. Melissa Sargent (D-Madison) says she has never used marijuana, but she has become the face of marijuana legalization in the past three legislative sessions. She has introduced legalization bills after hearing stories of the medical benefits that constituents have experienced and the negative consequences of marijuana-related arrests and convictions.
âI very quickly realized that the most dangerous thing about marijuana in Wisconsin was that it was illegal,â Sargent said.
This year, Sargent is working on a new bill that she said will go beyond Eversâ proposals and call for full legalization for both medical and recreational marijuana. As with Eversâ plan, Sargentâs bill would also allow nonviolent offenders to wipe marijuana-related possession convictions from their records âin ways that they currently cannot.â
When asked what he would say to lawmakers in Wisconsin in a one-minute pitch for legalization, Robinson responded, âI would definitely try to impress on them that cannabis is likely more popular in their district than they are.â
Sargent agreed: âPeople across the state of Wisconsin are far ahead of policymakers when it comes to this piece of legislation.â
Chisholm believes Eversâ proposal represents âan opportunity to educate everybody â even the people that are adamantly opposed to it.â
People such as Storck, who have long been waiting for legalization, hope that 2019 is not a repeat of the past.
âThe push for medical may be a step too far for some, as well as the proposed decriminalization, but these issues have majority popular support, and I hope the GOP will listen to the will of the people,â Storck said.
The Cannabis Question is a series by the Wisconsin Center for Investigative Journalism that explores questions about proposals to legalize marijuana in Wisconsin. This is the first installment. Additional stories will be published throughout the year. Do you have a story to tell? Contact us at [emailÂ protected].