When retired couple Heidi DeCoo and Carl Norton decided to buy a small co-op apartment in Manhattanâs Lenox Hill neighborhood as a city getaway from their home in Ithaca, N.Y., they encountered a strange request. The buildingâs co-op board asked that they bring their two gray-haired schnoodles (a cross between a miniature schnauzer and a poodle) in for their interview.
Ms. DeCoo had reservations. Farfel and Lilac were 13 years old and a 10-hour round trip car ride would be so taxing for them that the couple would have to find a dog-friendly Manhattan hotel in which to spend the night. To add to it, Farfel had recently slipped while jumping onto the furniture and torn a ligament. Still, the board insisted.
A few weeks later, Ms. DeCoo and Mr. Norton arrived for the meeting. Farfel, still recovering and on pain medication, was wheeled in a baby carriage. After the long car journey, the couple took them for a walk along the East River to tire Lilac in hopes of keeping her from jumping and barking around the board members, who would decide whether the coupleâand their poochesâwere a fit to buy the just under $500,000 apartment.
To Ms. DeCoo, the whole situation seemed absurd.
âBy the time they got out of the car, they were already sort of out of it. Lilac was being dragged along and Farfel was all stoned in his carriage,â she said. âI felt like a crazy old lady. When people see an old person with their dog in a baby carriage, they think theyâre nuts.â
For home buyers in New York, there are few things as daunting as the dreaded co-op board interview. Having examined an applicantâs financial statements, tax returns and recommendation letters, a panel convenes to judge, in person, whether a home buyer is up to snuff.
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
Could your pet successfully ace an applicant interview? Why or why not? Join the conversation below.
But adding pets to the interview process often means another layer of stressâand sometimes farceâfor would-be buyers. In most cases, dogs are shuttled into an apartment, where they are brought before a small panel of board members who interact with them for a few minutes and get a feel for whether theyâre likely to be problematic to residents.
âItâs an animal,â said real-estate agent Janna Raskopf. âItâs not like you can say to it, âWeâre going on an interview, so be on your best behavior.â â
While New York City co-op boards have been loosening up some of their restrictions to get deals done in a slow New York market, some boards are still eager to meet prospective buyersâ pets. The last thing co-ops want is for a dog to squat in the lobby, fight with another dog in the elevator or to have residents awakened by the early squawking of a bird, real-estate agents said.
Real-estate agent Barbara Fox said she recently had a client who was so terrified by the prospect of bringing her yappy poodle before the board of an Upper East Side co-op that the client ended up borrowing an older and more docile dog from a friend who had the same breed. She was accepted to the buildingâand the board still hasnât spotted the difference, Ms. Fox said, noting that she didnât have prior knowledge of the switch.
Other buyers are coming up with strategies to mitigate risk.
When buying a one-bedroom Lower East Side co-op for herself a few years back, real-estate agent Denise Bongiovanni said she sneaked some turkey slices into her pocket to keep her miniature dachshund Hershey under control.
âShe knew they were in there so she sat on my lap the whole time staring at me, wanting the turkey,â said Ms. Bongiovanni. âThe board was like, âSheâs so attentive!â I was thinking, âYes, she loves me but she loves the turkey more.â â
Bill Beauchamp and his partner walked their two dogs, Larry and Lainie, the 16 blocks to their interview for an East Village apartment in November in the hope that their energy levels might be slightly curbed. Lainie is a pure breed rat terrier and Larry is a Jack Russell and terrier mix.
âMy worst case scenario was that Lainie, the princess, would bark or jump on everyone and demand a tremendous amount of attention and Larry, who doesnât hear so well, would pay no attention to us and walk all over the place,â said Mr. Beauchamp, who is a real-estate agent at Citi Habitats. âWhen he doesnât like something, he will whine. And he canât really hear you when you say, âShut up, Larry.â â
In the end, both dogs were well-behaved and Mr. Beauchamp was approved. Similarly, Mr. Norton and Ms. DeCooâs pets were approved after what she described as a three- or four-minute meetup, during which a couple of board members took a quick look at the dogs in the hallway. âIt turned out to be much ado about nothing,â Mr. Norton said.
These interviews donât always go smoothly and it isnât uncommon for a buyer to be rejected because of their dog, said real estate attorney Michael J. Romer, noting that heâs had multiple clients disappointed.
Boards have reason to be selective as incidents like dog bites can open them up to legal liability. In some cases, boards are demanding headshots, rĂ©sumĂ©s and even recommendation letters specifically for pets to protect themselves.
Ms. Raskopf said she had a client whose dog had to sit with a third-party âdog whispererâ brought in by the board for a 10-minute evaluation, during which she just quietly observed the pooch. Occasionally, they bring another dog into the room to test their response.
One buyer recalled a board member going to their own apartment downstairs to see if they could hear her dogâs claws on the floor from their unit.
While it is common for applicants to take their dogs for long walks before the interview to exhaust them, some pet owners are going further and heading to the drug counter.
Stephen Geller, an agent with the Corcoran Group said he once had clients who took their terrier âto the shrinkâ before their interview for a roughly $2 million apartment in Kips Bay. âI remember I went to their house and they said âWeâre working on him. Weâre trying to figure out the right dose of Xanax and Zoloft. We donât want him to show up passed out.â â
Bash Dibra, a New York City dog trainer and author, said he doesnât recommend that route, since you donât want the dog to appear âdrugged out.â Mr. Dibra said heâs consulted with clients before interviews to help prepare their dogs for the process.
âEveryone cuts corners, but you have to be dogmatic about these things,â he joked.
Many pups are also showing up at interviews dressed to impress.
Mary Anne Greene, an agent with Douglas Elliman, said she once represented an older woman buying an apartment in a tony apartment building on Sutton Place who called her personal hair stylist to give her dog a blowout for the occasion. The miniature poodle named Baby also got a manicure and was dressed in pink bows and barrettes. The co-op board was amused. Baby passed.
Real-estate agent Jessica Levine recalled a client with a pit bull mix, who was dressed in a bow tie and sweater.
Already filled with trepidation about an interview at the Park Slope co-op where theyâd applied to purchase a $1.35 million apartment, Brooklynite Tory Peterschild, a software engineer, and her husband Sam LaCroix panicked when the agents on the deal, Luke Hoback and MaryElizabeth Smith of the Corcoran Group, said they might have to bring their dog Billie.
Bringing the adventurous three-year-old Goldendoodle posed some risks.
âShe is super lazy and relaxed when it is just us, but meeting people is her kryptonite,â Ms. Peterschild said. âShe just goes nuts. She likes to run through peopleâs legs from behind.â
So stressed was Ms. Peterschild about her interview that she considered giving Billie some CBD-infused treats to calm her before the interview. âBut we didnât want her to seem zoned out and weird,â she said.
They were relieved when the board was satisfied by the materials the couple sent about Billie and didnât request a pet interview. On a rĂ©sumĂ© put together by Ms. Peterschild, Billie is seen draping herself over the furniture in modelesque poses. Under likes, the couple lists treats, snoozing, playing fetch, tiny humans, radishes, apples and pears. Under qualifications, it reads âdoesnât shed.â
Many co-ops have banned certain more aggressive breeds. One particularly strict co-op on Lower Fifth Avenue has banned Alaskan Malamutes, Caucasian Mountain Dogs, Chihuahuas, Chow Chows, Dachshunds, Dalmatians, Doberman pinschers, German shepherds, Huskies, Jack Russell Terriers, Lhasa apsos, Old English Sheepdogs, Papillons, Pekingese, Pinschers, Pit Bulls, Presa Canarios, Rottweilers, Toy Poodles and Schnauzers, according to its rules.
The co-op, at 11 Fifth Avenue, says that approval for a dog will be given only if a resident signs a letter acknowledging that the dog can remain in the building solely at the boardâs discretion and that if, after a trial period, the board isnât happy, the dog can be removed.
And it isnât only dogs. Some boards are taking on birds too.
âIâve been calling myself the Dr. Dolittle of deals,â said agent Nicole Hay of Halstead Real Estate, who has helped multiple clients get their pets past the board.
One particularly memorable incident, which she has dubbed âParrotgate,â involved convincing the board of an Upper East Side co-op to accept a tropical four-inch-tall bird.
It was tricky. âThey said, âNo one wants to ride in an elevator with someone with a bird on their shoulder,â â Ms. Hay said. âI was shocked. It would be one thing if it was a Python or a Rottweiler. I had gray hairs from it, all because of this bird.â
Agent Janice Silver of Compass recalled an angry exchange between her and the property manager of a building on Gramercy Park after her clients were told to bring their parrot to an interview in the dead of winter.
âI explained that it was a tropical bird and very wrong to expect him to come out in freezing temperatures,â she said. âItâs not like a dog where you can wrap it up in a blanket. I had images of my clients standing out on the corner with the bird waiting for a cab.â
Help Fido Ace His Interview
Longtime dog trainer Elena Gretch of Itâs A Dogâs Life NY has prepared countless dogs for co-op board interviews. She shared some of her top tips.
1. Donât wait until the last minute
Ms. Gretch said she recommends all New York pups attend obedience training from an early age, rather than leave it until the last minute when a stressful situationâlike a co-op board interviewâcomes up. âItâs not realistic to expect to change your dogâs behavior in two weeks,â she said. She recommends a minimum of about three months of training to see a tangible change in a dog. So, if you know you have a co-op application coming up, start training right away.
2. Try to avoid the interview altogether
Ms. Gretch said she recommends putting together a packet for the board with the dogâs height, weight, vaccination records and recommendation letters from a veterinarian, a dog sitter and a neighbor. Even better, if the dog has completed any obedience training, include the certificate. You might get out of the interview by being proactive, she said.
3. Walk your dog
If you do have to interview with your dog, Ms. Gretch said she recommends some additional exercise before the appointment to expend some of the dogâs energy. But donât forget to give the dog a bath afterward. Boards donât like smelly dogs, either.
How the Board Decides
The board of a co-op building has to size up the pet of a prospective buyer in a short interview. They deploy some techniques to figure out who is a very good boy.
Sharon Fahy is president of her dog-friendly co-op board on East 74th Street. She said her board asks for pictures of pooches because occasionally buyers will tell fibs about their size, saying theyâre 50 pounds when theyâre really more like 90 pounds. Photos tell the real story, she says.
In an interview, she said she watches carefully to make sure that the pet is responding to its ownerâs commands and isnât noisy, like one dachshund who tortured residents of the building a few years back with its yelping throughout the day.
The board, she says, also looks at a petâs appearanceâfor instance, a dogâs coat and nailsâto make sure it is groomed properly. That points to a responsible owner, she said.
Write to Katherine Clarke at email@example.com
Copyright Â©2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. 87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8